Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Separate molecular identity from the origin of a feedstock
Two purified ethene batches come from different feedstock routes. Their molecular structures, isotope composition, purity and reaction conditions are stipulated to be identical.
| Batch A |
| Batch B |
Should source alone change the molecular formula?
Should the ideal polyethylene repeat differ between batches?
What additional evidence is needed to compare environmental impacts?
Question 10 - Solution
Separate molecular identity from the origin of a feedstock
| Batch A |
| Batch B |
(a)
No. Both batches contain C2H4 with the same bonding. A production label does not change molecular identity.
(b)
No. Under the stipulated identical chemistry, both give the same –CH2–CH2– repeat.
(c)
One needs process-specific evidence such as energy inputs, emissions and feedstock production. Identical molecules do not imply identical production impacts, and origin alone is not a quantitative assessment.