Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Recognize the limits of a substitution-count shortcut
Both ring alkenes have two carbon substituents on C=C by simple counting. Their ring sizes differ substantially.
| Cyclopropene |
| Cyclohexene |
Why does equal substitution count not imply equal strain?
Which ring forces the alkene geometry farther from its preferred angles?
Can simple counting alone supply a quantitative energy difference?
Question 10 - Solution
Recognize the limits of a substitution-count shortcut
| Cyclopropene |
| Cyclohexene |
(a)
The count ignores geometric constraints imposed by ring closure. Rings of different size can impose different angle and torsional strain.
(b)
The three-membered ring imposes much more severe angular constraints at the alkene carbons than the six-membered ring.
(c)
No. A numerical comparison requires appropriately referenced thermochemical data or calculations. Substitution count is only one structural factor.