Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
Interpret a primary isotope effect as evidence about the slow event
Only the isotope at the bond being broken changes. Other concentrations and conditions are matched.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate the kinetic isotope effect.
What does a sizable normal effect support?
Does this measurement alone prove that no intermediate exists?
Question 7 - Solution
Interpret a primary isotope effect as evidence about the slow event
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a)
The ratio k(H)/k(D) is 0.045/0.0090 = 5.0.
(b)
It supports significant involvement of C–H/C–D bond cleavage in the rate-controlling event under these conditions.
(c)
No. A stepwise route with rate-limiting deprotonation can also show an isotope effect. Combine it with rate laws and structural evidence rather than treating it as a unique mechanism label.