Drawing the Products of an E2 Reaction — Question 8

Section 8-8 · Organic Chemistry pages 1745–1746

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Reject an alkene product that requires a nonexistent carbon neighbor

A proposed ordinary E2 product is ethene. No reagent that supplies carbon is present.

Methyl bromide
  1. How many beta carbons does methyl bromide have?

  2. Why does the proposed product violate the carbon inventory?

  3. What mechanistic conclusion follows?

Question 8 - Solution

Reject an alkene product that requires a nonexistent carbon neighbor

Methyl bromide

(a)

It has no beta carbon: the carbon bearing Br has no carbon neighbor.

(b)

Methyl bromide contains one carbon, whereas ethene contains two. Ordinary beta elimination cannot create an extra carbon atom.

(c)

Ordinary alkene-forming E2 is unavailable for this substrate. A suitable nucleophile can instead react by substitution, but that is a different branch.