The E1 Mechanism — Question 4

Section 8-9 · Organic Chemistry pages 1757–1758

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Compare ordinary ionization prospects for three substrate classes

Compare simple alkyl substrates in the same suitable ionizing medium; exclude neighboring-group assistance and resonance stabilization.

A
B
C
  1. Classify the cation that each would form.

  2. Which has the strongest ordinary E1 propensity?

  3. Why is the same leaving group not enough to equalize their reactivity?

Question 4 - Solution

Compare ordinary ionization prospects for three substrate classes

A
B
C

(a)

A would form a primary cation, B a secondary cation and C a tertiary cation.

(b)

C has the strongest ordinary E1 propensity because its developing cation is best stabilized by alkyl substitution.

(c)

The ionization barrier depends on the substrate and developing charge as well as the leaving group. Simple primary ionization is generally unfavorable even with bromide present.