The E1 Mechanism — Question 5

Section 8-9 · Organic Chemistry pages 1759–1760

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Explain loss of strict starting-conformer memory in E1

Follow an E1 branch that forms a freely accessible cation and can change conformation before deprotonation.

Acyclic secondary bromide
  1. Must the removed H have been anti to Br in the original drawing?

  2. Can both but-2-ene geometries be accessible?

  3. Does loss of stereospecificity imply equal amounts of E and Z?

Question 5 - Solution

Explain loss of strict starting-conformer memory in E1

Acyclic secondary bromide

(a)

No. Br has already left before beta H removal, so the original H–C–C–Br anti relationship is not imposed as in direct E2.

(b)

Yes. Different accessible cation conformations can lead to E and Z but-2-ene, and a terminal alkene branch can also exist.

(c)

No. Different conformer populations, barriers and possible product equilibration can bias the ratio. E1 is not a rule requiring a 1:1 E/Z mixture.