Predicting Products of an Addition Reaction — Question 10

Section 9-12 · Organic Chemistry pages 2109–2110

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Avoid false precision for an unsymmetrical disubstituted alkene

Use ionic HBr. Ignore rearrangements and analyze only the two direct protonation/capture orientations.

Pent-2-ene
  1. Draw the two possible bromide connectivities.

  2. Does a primary-versus-tertiary carbocation argument distinguish these two branches?

  3. Can an exact 100:0 or 50:50 ratio be assigned from the drawing alone?

Question 10 - Solution

Avoid false precision for an unsymmetrical disubstituted alkene

2-Bromopentane
3-Bromopentane

(a)

The direct products are 2-bromopentane and 3-bromopentane.

(b)

No. Both direct protonation orientations give secondary carbocations; the simple substitution-level distinction is absent.

(c)

No. Their detailed energetics and conditions can affect selectivity. Neither exclusivity nor equal amounts follows from the information supplied.