Addition vs. Elimination: A Thermodynamic Perspective — Question 7

Section 9-2 · Organic Chemistry pages 1903–1904

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Compare isomeric alkenes through a common hydrogenation product

A denotes but-1-ene; B denotes one specified but-2-ene isomer. Conditions and endpoint are matched.

But-1-ene
But-2-ene

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Which reactant alkene has the lower enthalpy?

  2. Calculate their enthalpy difference.

  3. Why is a shared product important to this inference?

Question 7 - Solution

Compare isomeric alkenes through a common hydrogenation product

But-1-ene
But-2-ene

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

B has the lower enthalpy.

(b)

B lies 9 kJ/mol below A because A releases 9 kJ/mol more heat to reach the same endpoint.

(c)

Without a common endpoint, product energy differences would also contribute and could not be ignored.