Addition vs. Elimination: A Thermodynamic Perspective — Question 9

Section 9-2 · Organic Chemistry pages 1907–1908

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Explain why a two-to-one equation is not a complete entropy calculation

Compare this schematic equation in a gas-phase model with hydration in liquid water.

Alkene + H2O <=> Alcohol\text{Alkene + H2O <=> Alcohol}

  1. What qualitative entropy tendency is often associated with two gas molecules becoming one?

  2. Why should that count not be used as an exact liquid-phase Delta S?

  3. What data would support a quantitative free-energy prediction?

Question 9 - Solution

Explain why a two-to-one equation is not a complete entropy calculation

Alkene + H2O <=> Alcohol\text{Alkene + H2O <=> Alcohol}

(a)

A loss of translational freedom often makes gas-phase addition entropically unfavorable.

(b)

In solution, solvation, solvent reorganization, standard states and mixing matter. Stoichiometric molecule counting alone does not give the entropy change.

(c)

Matched reaction enthalpy and entropy data, or standard chemical potentials/equilibrium data, are needed at the stated temperature and conditions.