Hydrohalogenation — Question 9

Section 9-3 · Organic Chemistry pages 1927–1928

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Identify the missing condition in an anti-Markovnikov claim

Only ordinary ionic HBr addition is specified. Radical chemistry is outside this problem.

But-1-ene

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Is the proposed primary bromide the expected major ionic product?

  2. Give the expected major connectivity.

  3. Why must a different mechanistic claim state its conditions?

Question 9 - Solution

Identify the missing condition in an anti-Markovnikov claim

Expected ionic product

(a)

No. Ordinary ionic addition favors the secondary cation and the secondary bromide.

(b)

The expected principal connectivity is 2-bromobutane.

(c)

Changing mechanism can change orientation. An anti-Markovnikov HBr claim cannot simply be imported into an ionic problem without specifying the conditions that support a different pathway.