Show solutionHide solution
Question 2
Find the confounding variable
Team A dissolves crushed crystals in 100 mL of water at with stirring. Team B uses whole crystals in 150 mL at without stirring. Team A finishes first.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Can the result isolate an effect of temperature? Explain.
Redesign the comparison to test particle size alone.
Why are repeated trials still needed after the redesign?
Question 2 - Solution
Find the confounding variable
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Diagnose confounding
No. Temperature, particle size, water volume, and stirring differ together. Each could contribute to the observed time difference, so the temperature effect is not isolated.
(b) Change one factor
Use equal masses of the same solid, equal water volumes, the same temperature and vessels, and the same stirring protocol. Compare a defined small particle-size range with a defined large range; keep the endpoint identical.
(c) Assess repeatability
Repeats reveal variation in timing, endpoint judgment, and sample preparation. An apparent difference smaller than this variation is weak evidence for a particle-size effect.
Check and interpretation
Repetition reduces uncertainty about a comparison but cannot repair a confounded design.