The Scientific Method — Question 3

Section 1-2 · Chemistry pages 31–32

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Two models fit the initial experiment

Two models describe a hypothetical sensor response RR in arbitrary units as a function of concentration cc in mg/L: RA=2cR_A=2c and RB=2c+0.10c2R_B=2c+0.10c^2, using numerical values in the stated units. At c=1.0c=1.0, readings have a stated bound of ±0.3\pm0.3 response unit.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate both predictions at c=1.0c=1.0 and decide whether that measurement can clearly distinguish them.

  2. Calculate both predictions at c=5.0c=5.0. Assume the same reading bound and that the sensor remains usable.

  3. Explain why agreement with one additional point would support, but not prove, a model.

Question 3 - Solution

Two models fit the initial experiment

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Compare close predictions

RA=2.0,RB=2.1,|RB−RA|=0.1.R_A=2.0,\qquad R_B=2.1,\qquad |R_B-R_A|=0.1.The separation is smaller than the reading bound, so this point provides little discrimination.

(b) Choose a discriminating condition

RA=10.0,RB=10.0+0.10(25)=12.5.R_A=10.0,\qquad R_B=10.0+0.10(25)=12.5.The separation of 2.5 units greatly exceeds the stated bound. A controlled measurement here can discriminate much more strongly.

(c) Limit confirmation

A finite number of matches cannot exclude all alternative models or establish behavior outside the tested range. Independent concentrations and calibration checks are still needed.

Check and interpretation

Good experiment design targets conditions where plausible explanations make different predictions.