Uncertainty in Measurement — Question 8

Section 1-4 · Chemistry pages 81–82

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

More repetitions reduce one uncertainty component

A measurement method has a known random standard deviation σ=0.12\sigma=0.12 g per reading. Assume independent readings of a stable sample with the same distribution. The standard uncertainty of their mean is um‾=σ/nu_{\bar m}=\sigma/\sqrt{n}. An uncorrected, constant calibration offset of +0.08+0.08 g affects every reading.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate um‾u_{\bar m} for n=4n=4 and n=36n=36.

  2. How many readings are needed to reduce this random component to 0.01 g or less under the model?

  3. Does collecting 36 readings remove the calibration offset? Is m‾±um‾\bar m\pm u_{\bar m} a guaranteed interval?

Question 8 - Solution

More repetitions reduce one uncertainty component

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Apply the supplied model

u4=0.124=0.06g,u36=0.1236=0.02g.u_4=\frac{0.12}{\sqrt4}=0.06\ \mathrm g,\qquad u_{36}=\frac{0.12}{\sqrt{36}}=0.02\ \mathrm g.Nine times as many readings reduce this component by a factor of three, not nine.

(b) Find the required sample count

0.12n≤0.01⇒n≥12⇒n≥144.\frac{0.12}{\sqrt n}\leq0.01\quad\Longrightarrow\quad\sqrt n\geq12\quad\Longrightarrow\quad\boxed{n\geq144}.This conclusion depends on the stated independence and stability assumptions.

(c) Separate random spread from offset

The constant +0.08+0.08 g offset remains in the mean regardless of nn; it requires calibration correction. A standard uncertainty describes a statistical spread, not a guaranteed bound. Without an additional distributional model, no specific coverage probability follows for m‾±um‾\bar m\pm u_{\bar m}.

Check and interpretation

At n=36n=36, the offset is four times the random standard uncertainty. More readings alone cannot remove it.