Temperature — Question 6

Section 1-7 · Chemistry pages 137–138

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Correct both the zero error and the span error

A thermometer reports an indicated numerical Celsius value rr. At a true 0.0∘C0.0^\circ\mathrm C it reads 2.0, and at a true 100.0∘C100.0^\circ\mathrm C it reads 104.0. For this exercise, treat the two calibration pairs as exact and assume r=atC+br=a t_C+b across the interval.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Determine aa and bb, and write the equation for correcting an indication.

  2. Find the corrected temperature for an indication of 53.0. Report to 0.1 degree.

  3. A student simply subtracts 2.0 from every reading. Evaluate this method at 53.0 and 104.0, and explain why a second calibration point is useful.

Question 6 - Solution

Correct both the zero error and the span error

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Fit the linear calibration

b=2.0,a=104.0−2.0100.0−0.0=1.02.b=2.0,\qquad a=\frac{104.0-2.0}{100.0-0.0}=1.02.r=1.02tC+2.0,tC=r−2.01.02.r=1.02t_C+2.0,\qquad\boxed{t_C=\frac{r-2.0}{1.02}}.The intercept represents the zero error; the slope differs from the ideal value of one.

(b) Correct the indication

tC=53.0−2.01.02=50.0∘C.t_C=\frac{53.0-2.0}{1.02}=\boxed{50.0^\circ\mathrm C}.Subtract the offset and then correct the scale factor. Applying only one of these operations is insufficient.

(c) Test the shortcut

Offset-only correction gives 53.0−2.0=51.0∘C53.0-2.0=51.0^\circ\mathrm C, which is 1.0 degree too high. At 104.0 it gives 102.0∘C102.0^\circ\mathrm C, two degrees too high. A second calibration point detects span error. Real measurements would also require calibration uncertainties and evidence that the linear model is adequate.

Check and interpretation

The corrected endpoint indications recover 0 and 100∘C100^\circ\mathrm C, as required by the assumed calibration model.