Temperature — Question 8

Section 1-7 · Chemistry pages 141–142

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Temperature is not a measure of how much material is present

Three insulated cups initially contain liquid water: A has 50 g at 60∘C60^\circ\mathrm C, B has 500 g at 60∘C60^\circ\mathrm C, and C has 50 g at 20∘C20^\circ\mathrm C. Consider only heat transfer caused by temperature differences, with no phase change or chemical reaction.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Is B hotter than A because it contains more water? If A and B are placed in thermal contact, is there an initial net heat flow between them?

  2. If A and C are instead placed in thermal contact, state the initial direction of heat flow. Does C's smaller numerical temperature mean it has no internal energy?

  3. Explain why temperature alone is insufficient to determine a sample's total internal energy.

Question 8 - Solution

Temperature is not a measure of how much material is present

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Compare temperatures, not amounts

A and B have equal temperature, 60∘C60^\circ\mathrm C. The larger water mass does not make B hotter. With equal temperatures there is no initial net heat transfer between them driven by a temperature difference.

(b) Identify the thermal direction

Initially heat flows from warmer A to cooler C. The 20∘C20^\circ\mathrm C reading does not imply zero internal energy; Celsius zero is an assigned reference, and a temperature reading is not a direct measure of the total energy in a sample.

(c) Distinguish intensive and extensive properties

Temperature is intensive: it does not scale with sample amount. Total internal energy depends on amount, substance and state, as well as temperature and the energy reference used. For equal-composition water at the same thermodynamic state, increasing the amount scales its extensive internal energy; temperature alone cannot specify that total.

Check and interpretation

A and B provide the counterexample: the same temperature can describe samples containing very different amounts of material.