Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
A dense metal can form a low-density sealed object
A sealed object made only of copper and a negligible-mass air cavity has mass 44.5 g and external volume . Copper density is . A proposed alternative is a cavity-free copper–aluminum mixture; aluminum density is . Assume metal volumes add in that alternative.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Find the object's bulk density and its cavity volume under the copper-shell model.
For a cavity-free mixture, use to find the copper volume fraction that would give the same bulk density.
Can mass and external volume alone distinguish the two models? Suggest an observation that can discriminate.
Question 9 - Solution
A dense metal can form a low-density sealed object
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Infer a cavity under a stated model
This inference depends on the copper-only assumption.
(b) Construct a competing model
About 46.2% copper by volume, with the rest aluminum, reproduces the same density in the additive-volume model. This is not a mass fraction.
(c) Assess identifiability
No: both models reproduce the two bulk measurements. Imaging the interior could reveal a cavity, while elemental analysis could test for aluminum. Agreement with a density calculation does not uniquely establish internal structure or composition.
Check and interpretation
The bulk density lies between the two metal densities, so a mixture fraction between zero and one is possible.