Show solutionHide solution
Question 3
Distinguish a change of state from a change of chemical identity
Four observations concern closed systems: A, pure water freezes; B, pure water boils with no decomposition; C, water is electrolyzed and verified hydrogen and oxygen gases form; D, a liquid releases visible bubbles when warmed, but the gas is not identified. A chemical change forms new substances.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Classify A, B and C as physical or chemical changes, explaining what happens to chemical identity.
Is bubbling alone sufficient to classify D? Give two different explanations consistent with the observation.
Explain why unchanged total mass in a closed system cannot distinguish a physical change from a chemical change.
Question 3 - Solution
Distinguish a change of state from a change of chemical identity
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Use substance identity
A and B are physical changes: water remains water while its state changes. C is a chemical change: hydrogen and oxygen are new substances formed from water. The evidence identifying the products, not their gaseous state, establishes the chemical change.
(b) Recognize ambiguous evidence
No. The bubbles could be vapor from boiling, or gas previously dissolved in the liquid escaping. Gas formation from a chemical reaction is also possible. Gas identity and other evidence are needed; visible bubbles alone do not decide.
(c) Apply conservation in both cases
For ordinary physical and chemical changes, matter is conserved in a closed system. In a chemical change atoms are rearranged into new substances; in a physical change the chemical identity remains. Equal mass before and after is consistent with either process.
Check and interpretation
Boiling water and decomposing water both can produce gases, but they are different kinds of change.