Classification of Matter — Question 9

Section 1-9 · Chemistry pages 183–184

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

New particles do not guarantee a pure product sample

The before-and-after diagrams show all particles in a closed hypothetical reaction. A and B are different elements, lines are bonds, and the only reaction allowed is A2+B2→2ABA_2+B_2\longrightarrow2AB. Each drawn particle represents one molecule for counting purposes.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Count A and B atoms before and after. Is the proposed diagram consistent with atom conservation?

  2. Classify the initial sample and final sample by the substances present. Is the final sample a pure compound?

  3. Explain whether the change is chemical and why an unchanged number of total molecules would not imply a physical change.

Question 9 - Solution

New particles do not guarantee a pure product sample

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Count atoms, not just symbols of species

Initially there are three A2A_2 and two B2B_2: six A atoms and four B atoms. Finally there are four AB and one A2A_2: again six A atoms and four B atoms. The diagram conserves each element. Two A2A_2 and two B2B_2 have reacted, leaving one A2A_2.

(b) Classify both inventories

The initial sample is a mixture of two elements. The final sample is a mixture of compound AB and elemental A2A_2; it is not pure AB. Producing a compound does not require every starting substance to be consumed.

(c) Identify the change in bonding

The change is chemical: new AB molecules form through rearrangement of bonds. Both drawings contain five molecules, but equal molecule count does not preserve chemical identity. In general, reactions conserve atoms, not necessarily the number of molecules.

Check and interpretation

All B atoms are now in AB, while two A atoms remain together as A2A_2.