Classification of Matter — Question 10

Section 1-9 · Chemistry pages 185–186

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Use sampling evidence to test a claim of homogeneity

Three 10.0 g liquid aliquots are taken simultaneously from the top, middle and bottom of an undisturbed vessel. Gentle evaporation removes all volatile material and leaves dry residues of 0.20, 0.50 and 0.80 g, respectively. No reaction occurs, and sampling and weighing errors are negligible compared with the differences. All nonvolatile material is retained.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the residue mass percentage in each aliquot. Is the original vessel homogeneous in composition?

  2. If only these three aliquots are combined and mixed uniformly without loss, calculate their combined residue mass percentage.

  3. Does evaporation establish that the residue is a pure compound, or that the volatile material was pure water? State what the experiment actually establishes.

Question 10 - Solution

Use sampling evidence to test a claim of homogeneity

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Compare equal-mass samples

The residue percentages are 100(0.20/10.0)=2.0%100(0.20/10.0)=2.0\%, 100(0.50/10.0)=5.0%100(0.50/10.0)=5.0\% and 100(0.80/10.0)=8.0%100(0.80/10.0)=8.0\%. Composition depends on sampling position, so the original vessel is not homogeneous. The results do not by themselves determine the number of phases.

(b) Combine the sampled amounts

mresidue=0.20+0.50+0.80=1.50g,mtotal=30.0g.m_{\mathrm{residue}}=0.20+0.50+0.80=1.50\ \mathrm g,\quad m_{\mathrm{total}}=30.0\ \mathrm g.1001.5030.0=5.00%.100\frac{1.50}{30.0}=\boxed{5.00\%}.This describes the combined aliquots, not necessarily the whole vessel; the three positions need not represent equal masses of the vessel contents.

(c) Respect the limit of the separation

Neither identity claim follows. The residue could contain one or several nonvolatile substances; the evaporated material could contain one or several volatile substances. The experiment measures nonvolatile mass fractions under the stated conditions and reveals their variation with position, not the identities or purity of the fractions.

Check and interpretation

The combined fraction lies between 2.0% and 8.0%, as a positive mass-weighted average must.