Spontaneous Processes and Entropy — Question 10

Section 16-1 · Chemistry pages 2705–2706

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Replace vague disorder language with a testable model

A solid forms a highly ordered crystal while releasing heat to a large reservoir. A second process mixes two ideal gases at constant temperature.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain why crystal formation can still occur spontaneously even if the material entropy decreases.

  2. Give a more precise interpretation of gas mixing than saying that the appearance becomes messier.

Question 10 - Solution

Replace vague disorder language with a testable model

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The crystal is only part of the thermodynamic universe. Entropy gained by the reservoir can exceed the decrease in the crystallizing material, yielding a positive total entropy change.

(b) Analysis

Distinct gas species gain accessible spatial configurations when each can occupy the combined volume. Entropy quantifies the number and probabilities of accessible microscopic states, not visual untidiness.

Check and interpretation

An ordered subsystem need not imply a decrease in total entropy.