Free Energy and Work — Question 6

Section 16-9 · Chemistry pages 2857–2858

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Calculate a minimum work input for separating gases

Unless stated otherwise, use constant temperature and pressure, a closed system, and reversible pressure-volume exchange with the surroundings. Define useful work as work other than pressure-volume work; useful output is positive. At 298 K an ideal mixture contains 0.500 mol A and 0.500 mol distinct gas B. It is separated into pure gases at the same T and pressure. Use R=8.31446R=8.31446 J mol−1^{-1} K−1^{-1} and ΔGmix=RT∑niln⁡yi\Delta G_{mix}=RT\sum n_i\ln y_i.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the minimum useful separation work input.

  2. Explain why a perfect selective membrane does not make separation require zero work.

Question 6 - Solution

Calculate a minimum work input for separating gases

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Mixing these pure gases would give ΔGmix=RTln⁡(0.5)=−1.71742\Delta G_{mix}=RT\ln(0.5)=-1.71742 kJ. Reversing that state change requires at least +1.71742 kJ of useful input.

(b) Analysis

Selectivity can provide a reversible pathway but does not remove the entropy decrease of separation. The necessary work compensates the loss of mixing entropy through interaction with the surroundings.

Check and interpretation

The limit depends on compositions and final states; real separators require more work.