Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Choose the law that addresses the actual comparison
Three observations are supplied: I, total mass before and after a closed reaction is equal; II, all pure samples of compound X have the same elemental mass ratio; III, two distinct compounds of the same two elements have B masses in ratio 3:4 when compared at fixed A mass.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Match each observation to conservation of mass, definite proportions or multiple proportions.
Explain why II and III are not contradictory.
Would comparison of compounds containing entirely different pairs of elements directly test multiple proportions?
Question 8 - Solution
Choose the law that addresses the actual comparison
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
I illustrates conservation of mass. II illustrates definite proportions. III illustrates multiple proportions.
(b) Analysis
Definite proportions concerns one compound across samples. Multiple proportions compares different compounds made from the same elements. Each compound can have its own fixed composition while their normalized ratios differ.
(c) Conclusion
No. The comparison requires the same two elements and a fixed mass of one. Otherwise changes in elemental identity prevent the stated law from being tested directly.
Check and interpretation
Identify what is held fixed: system mass, compound identity, or one element's mass.