Show solutionHide solution
Question 6
Revise a postulate without discarding the whole theory
A simplified Dalton postulate states that all atoms of one element have identical mass. Modern measurements find two kinds of chlorine atom with the same proton count but different neutron counts and different masses. Such forms are called isotopes.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Which part of the simplified postulate requires revision?
What feature keeps the two atoms in the same element?
Why does isotope evidence not by itself refute atom conservation in ordinary chemical reactions?
Question 6 - Solution
Revise a postulate without discarding the whole theory
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The identical-mass claim must be revised: atoms of one element can be isotopes with different masses. Chemical identity need not imply one universal atomic mass.
(b) Analysis
They have the same number of protons. In the modern classification, proton count defines the element; neutron count distinguishes isotopes.
(c) Conclusion
Chemical reactions can rearrange these atoms without changing their nuclei. Different isotopic masses are compatible with conserving each atom and the total mass to ordinary chemical precision. One inaccurate postulate does not invalidate every prediction of the model.
Check and interpretation
A theory can retain useful conservation and combination ideas while its internal picture is refined.