Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Find and repair an impossible product inventory
An initial hypothetical inventory contains four molecules and three molecules. A student draws six product molecules and no leftovers. The only allowed reaction produces , and atoms must be conserved.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Count the initial and claimed final atoms of each element.
Explain why the drawing is impossible.
Find the maximum number of particles and specify the unused atoms.
Question 8 - Solution
Find and repair an impossible product inventory
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Initially there are eight A and six B atoms. Six would contain six A and twelve B atoms.
(b) Analysis
The drawing creates six B atoms and fails to account for two A atoms. It violates conservation of each element, even though six particles may look plausible.
(c) Conclusion
Six B atoms can supply only three particles. Those use three A atoms, leaving five A atoms. The grouping of the unused A atoms is unspecified; atom accounting alone does not determine how they are bonded.
Check and interpretation
The repaired inventory has three A in product plus five unused A, and all six B in product.