Dalton’s Atomic Theory — Question 9

Section 2-3 · Chemistry pages 243–244

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Distinguish chemical combination from equal bulk counts

Box P contains four AB particles. Box Q contains four separate A atoms and four separate B atoms, with no A–B bonds. Assume both boxes contain the same kinds of A and B atoms.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Compare the total A and B counts and masses in the two boxes.

  2. Why can the boxes nevertheless represent chemically different samples?

  3. Which statement from the atomic model explains why a compound is not just an arbitrary mechanical blend?

Question 9 - Solution

Distinguish chemical combination from equal bulk counts

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Both boxes contain four A and four B atoms. Under the same atomic-mass assumptions their total masses and elemental mass fractions are equal.

(b) Analysis

P contains a compound with A and B combined in identical AB particles. Q is a mixture of uncombined elements. Bonding and particle identity differ even though elemental totals match.

(c) Conclusion

Compounds are formed by atoms of different elements combining in definite numerical relationships. The relationship within compound particles, not only the aggregate number of atoms present, matters.

Check and interpretation

Counting elements is necessary for conservation, but not sufficient for identifying chemical species.