Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
Count a population of isotopes without inventing fractional atoms
A model sample contains 80 neutral carbon-12 atoms and 20 neutral carbon-13 atoms. Carbon has . Treat the given counts as exact.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Find the total protons, neutrons and electrons in the sample.
Find the mean mass number per atom.
Explain why this mean does not imply that any one atom has a fractional neutron count.
Question 5 - Solution
Count a population of isotopes without inventing fractional atoms
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
There are protons and 600 electrons. Neutrons total .
(b) Analysis
The total nucleon count is , so the mean mass number is . This is a count-based average, not a precise average atomic mass.
(c) Conclusion
Each carbon-12 atom has six neutrons and each carbon-13 atom has seven. Averaging an integer-valued population can produce a noninteger mean without requiring fractional particles in any member.
Check and interpretation
Total protons plus total neutrons equals 1220, agreeing with the summed mass numbers.