The Modern View of Atomic Structure: An Introduction — Question 6

Section 2-5 · Chemistry pages 277–278

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Estimate how little mass is removed when an electron is lost

For a simple estimate, assign a neutral sodium atom a total mass of 23.0 u and an electron mass of 5.49×10−45.49\times10^{-4} u. Removing one electron produces Na+\mathrm{Na}^{+}. Ignore binding-energy corrections in this estimate.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Estimate the mass removed in u and as a percentage of the initial atom mass.

  2. Does the mass number change when the electron leaves?

  3. Why is it reasonable in introductory particle accounting to say most atomic mass is in the nucleus while still recognizing that electrons have mass?

Question 6 - Solution

Estimate how little mass is removed when an electron is lost

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The removed mass is 5.49×10−45.49\times10^{-4} u. The fraction is (5.49×10−4)/23.0=2.3869…×10−5(5.49\times10^{-4})/23.0=2.3869\ldots\times10^{-5}, so the percentage is 0.00239%\boxed{0.00239\%} to three significant figures.

(b) Analysis

No. Electron loss changes charge, not the proton-plus-neutron count. The isotope remains sodium-23 if that was the starting isotope.

(c) Conclusion

Each electron is much lighter than a nucleon. Their total mass is small relative to the nuclear mass for ordinary atoms, but not literally zero. The numerical estimate makes the approximation explicit.

Check and interpretation

The ion mass is slightly smaller even though its mass number is unchanged.