An Introduction to the Periodic Table — Question 4

Section 2-7 · Chemistry pages 313–314

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Predict simple ions from electron gain and loss

For this exercise, Na (Z=11Z=11) loses one electron, Mg (Z=12Z=12) loses two, O (Z=8Z=8) gains two and Cl (Z=17Z=17) gains one when forming their common monatomic ions.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Write all four ions with charges.

  2. Find the electron count of each ion.

  3. Explain why a negative sign represents electron gain rather than loss of a proton.

Question 4 - Solution

Predict simple ions from electron gain and loss

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The ions are Na+,Mg2+,O2−,Cl−\boxed{Na^+,\ Mg^{2+},\ O^{2-},\ Cl^-}. These illustrate common simple main-group charge patterns.

(b) Analysis

Electron counts are 10 for Na+Na^+, 10 for Mg2+Mg^{2+}, 10 for O2−O^{2-} and 18 for Cl−Cl^-.

(c) Conclusion

Electrons carry negative charge. Adding them makes the charge more negative while proton count and element identity remain fixed. Removing a proton would change the element and would be a nuclear change.

Check and interpretation

The shared electron count of three ions does not make their nuclear charges or identities equal.