An Introduction to the Periodic Table — Question 8

Section 2-7 · Chemistry pages 321–322

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Do not read a transition-metal charge from the column number

Iron is in group 8. In the simple ionic models for FeO and Fe2O3Fe_2O_3, each oxygen is O2−O^{2-} and each iron in a given compound has the same charge.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the iron charge in FeO.

  2. Find the iron charge in Fe2O3Fe_2O_3.

  3. Why is assigning Fe8+Fe^{8+} merely from group 8 unjustified?

Question 8 - Solution

Do not read a transition-metal charge from the column number

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Neutral FeO requires qFe−2=0q_{Fe}-2=0, giving Fe2+Fe^{2+}.

(b) Analysis

Neutral Fe2O3Fe_2O_3 requires 2qFe+3(−2)=02q_{Fe}+3(-2)=0, giving Fe3+Fe^{3+}.

(c) Conclusion

The group number labels a column, not a universal monatomic-ion charge. Transition metals commonly exhibit more than one oxidation state. The actual compound composition and charge model supply the relevant information here.

Check and interpretation

Both compounds contain the same element even though the iron charge assignment differs.