The Group 5A Elements — Question 8

Section 20-1 · Chemistry pages 3301–3302

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Classify oxides using their observed reactions

Hypothetical Group 5A oxides A, B and C show the following behavior: A reacts with base to give an oxyanion; B reacts with both acid and base; C reacts with acid to give a dissolved metal species.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Classify A, B and C by acid-base behavior and relate the pattern to increasing metallic character down the group.

  2. Explain why oxidation state and experimental conditions must be controlled before treating this as a universal monotonic trend.

Question 8 - Solution

Classify oxides using their observed reactions

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

A is acidic, B amphoteric and C basic under the stated conditions. Increasing metallic character often favors more basic oxides, whereas covalent nonmetal oxides often behave as acid anhydrides.

(b) Analysis

Changing oxidation state changes bonding and electron withdrawal, while solvent, concentration and temperature can change what reacts or dissolves. The observations support a conditional trend, not a claim that every oxide of a later element is more basic than every oxide of an earlier one.

Check and interpretation

Classify the observed chemistry before assigning a broad periodic explanation.