The Group 5A Elements — Question 9

Section 20-1 · Chemistry pages 3303–3304

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Infer an atomic mass from a trichloride composition

A pure compound has formula ECl3ECl_3 and contains 22.55 percent E by mass. Use chlorine molar mass 35.45 g/mol. Candidate atomic molar masses are N = 14.0, P = 31.0 and As = 74.9 g/mol.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Infer the atomic molar mass of E and identify the best candidate.

  2. Explain why the answer would change if the assumed formula were incorrect, and propose a useful independent check.

Question 9 - Solution

Infer an atomic mass from a trichloride composition

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Let M be the molar mass of E. Then M/(M+3(35.45))=0.2255M/(M+3(35.45))=0.2255, giving M=0.2255(106.35)/0.7745=30.96M=0.2255(106.35)/0.7745=30.96 g/mol. Phosphorus is the matching candidate within the supplied precision.

(b) Analysis

The inversion uses the assumed 1:3 atom ratio. A pentachloride or mixture would give a different inferred M from the same mass percentage. An independent molar-mass measurement or an elemental atom-ratio determination could test the proposed formula and sample purity.

Check and interpretation

Composition supports identity only within the stated stoichiometric model.