The Group 5A Elements — Question 10

Section 20-1 · Chemistry pages 3305–3306

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Design a fair test of a periodic trend

A student claims that electrical conductivity always increases down Group 5A because atoms become larger. Measurements supplied for two phosphorus allotropes differ by several orders of magnitude, although both have the same atomic number.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain why the allotrope evidence challenges the proposed single-variable explanation.

  2. Design a comparison across the group that separates periodic identity from phase, purity and temperature effects, and state an appropriate conclusion if exceptions remain.

Question 10 - Solution

Design a fair test of a periodic trend

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Allotropes change bonding, crystal structure and accessible electronic states without changing the element or atomic size in the proposed periodic sense. Conductivity therefore cannot be determined by row position alone.

(b) Analysis

Compare characterized phases at the same temperature and pressure, document purity and defects, use consistent sample geometry and contact methods, and report uncertainty. A broad rise in metallic character may coexist with structural exceptions; report the conditional trend and exceptions rather than declaring an exact law.

Check and interpretation

A periodic trend is an organizing principle, not a substitute for controlled evidence.