The Group 6A Elements — Question 3

Section 20-4 · Chemistry pages 3351–3352

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Explain an electron-affinity exception

For isolated gaseous atoms, use electron-attachment enthalpies O+e−→O−O+e^-\to O^-: -141 kJ/mol, and S+e−→S−S+e^-\to S^-: -200 kJ/mol. Negative values mean energy release.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Identify which first electron attachment is more exothermic and calculate the difference.

  2. Explain how crowding in a compact valence shell can compete with nuclear attraction, and why these data do not determine formation of O2−O^{2-} or S2−S^{2-} in a crystal.

Question 3 - Solution

Explain an electron-affinity exception

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Sulfur attachment is more exothermic by 200−141=59200-141=59 kJ/mol. A more negative attachment enthalpy corresponds to a larger energy release under this sign convention.

(b) Analysis

Oxygen's compact 2p shell has strong electron-electron repulsions when an extra electron is added; the larger sulfur shell can reduce this crowding. Making a dianion requires a second attachment, and crystal formation also includes cation formation, atomization and lattice stabilization. First attachment alone is incomplete.

Check and interpretation

State the sign convention before comparing electron affinities.