Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
Interpret bond angles without making hybridization a measurement
Approximate gas-phase bond angles are 104.5 degrees for water, 92 degrees for and 91 degrees for . Each molecule has two E-H bonds and two lone pairs in an elementary Lewis model.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Explain why all three molecules are bent, yet the same four-domain label does not predict identical bond angles.
Assess the claim that each measured angle proves the central atom uses four perfectly equivalent tetrahedral hybrid orbitals.
Question 5 - Solution
Interpret bond angles without making hybridization a measurement
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The two lone pairs occupy electron density around the central atom, while only two bonded atoms define molecular shape; a bent arrangement follows. Quantitative angles depend on orbital energies, bond character and electron interactions, not only the number of domains.
(b) Analysis
Angles near 90 degrees for the heavier hydrides are inconsistent with treating four equivalent ideal tetrahedral directions as an exact description. Hybrid orbitals are a model used to describe bonding, not directly counted objects established uniquely by an angle measurement.
Check and interpretation
Use an electron-domain model as a qualitative guide and compare its predictions with data.