The Transition Metals: A Survey — Question 1

Section 21-1 · Chemistry pages 3447–3448

Show solutionHide solution

Question 1

Apply a transition-element definition consistently

For this assignment, a transition element has an incomplete d subshell in its atom or in a commonly formed cation. Use Cu: [Ar]3d104s1[Ar]3d^{10}4s^1, Cu2+:3d9Cu^{2+}:3d^9; Zn: [Ar]3d104s2[Ar]3d^{10}4s^2, Zn2+:3d10Zn^{2+}:3d^{10}; Sc: [Ar]3d14s2[Ar]3d^14s^2, Sc3+:3d0Sc^{3+}:3d^0.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Classify Cu, Zn and Sc under the stated definition.

  2. Explain why neither a filled d subshell in one neutral atom nor an empty d subshell in one ion is sufficient by itself to exclude an element.

Question 1 - Solution

Apply a transition-element definition consistently

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Cu qualifies because its common +2 ion has an incomplete d subshell. Sc qualifies because its neutral atom has an incomplete d subshell. Zn does not qualify under this definition because both the stated atom and common ion have filled d subshells.

(b) Analysis

The definition allows an incomplete d subshell in either the atom or a commonly formed cation. Cu and Sc illustrate the two alternatives. Placement in the d block and a strict transition-element definition need not give exactly identical lists.

Check and interpretation

The classification follows an explicitly stated convention rather than an unexplained label.