Bonding in Complex Ions: The Localized Electron Model — Question 8

Section 21-5 · Chemistry pages 3541–3542

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Recognize that five donor directions do not uniquely specify shape

Two hypothetical complexes each contain five monodentate donor atoms. A has two axial donors and three equatorial donors separated by 120 degrees. B has four donors at square-base corners and one above the square.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Identify the two geometries and explain why counting five acceptor orbitals alone does not distinguish them.

  2. Name a geometric measurement that would distinguish A from B without relying on a hybridization label.

Question 8 - Solution

Recognize that five donor directions do not uniquely specify shape

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

A is trigonal bipyramidal and B is square pyramidal. Five donor directions can be arranged in more than one geometry; an orbital-count label cannot supply all angular information.

(b) Analysis

Determine ligand-metal-ligand angles and donor positions by structural measurement. A has three equatorial 120-degree separations and a pair of opposite axial donors; B has a square base with neighboring 90-degree and opposite 180-degree angles plus one apical donor.

Check and interpretation

Geometry is an observation to explain, not a consequence of counting orbitals alone.