The Crystal Field Model — Question 6

Section 21-6 · Chemistry pages 3557–3558

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Show why a magnetic moment may not distinguish two d8 geometries

For tetrahedral d8 use lower e levels at −0.6Δt-0.6\Delta_t and upper t2 levels at +0.4Δt+0.4\Delta_t. For octahedral d8 use the usual t2g/eg splitting. Assume conventional Hund filling within degenerate sets.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Fill each geometry, count unpaired electrons and find its CFSE in terms of its own splitting.

  2. Using Δt=(4/9)Δo\Delta_t=(4/9)\Delta_o only as an illustrative comparison, explain why these CFSE values alone cannot prove which coordination number will be preferred.

Question 6 - Solution

Show why a magnetic moment may not distinguish two d8 geometries

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Tetrahedral filling is e4t24e^4t_2^4, with two unpaired electrons and CFSE 4(−0.6)+4(0.4)=−0.8Δt4(-0.6)+4(0.4)=-0.8\Delta_t. Octahedral filling is t2g6eg2t_{2g}^6e_g^2, also two unpaired electrons, with CFSE −1.2Δo-1.2\Delta_o. Thus spin count alone does not distinguish them.

(b) Analysis

The tetrahedral value becomes −(0.8)(4/9)Δo=−0.3556Δo-(0.8)(4/9)\Delta_o=-0.3556\Delta_o. But different coordination numbers involve different ligand inventories, overall bonding and reference energies, with pairing and other terms as well. Comparing only splitting stabilization is not a complete geometry-selection calculation.

Check and interpretation

Equal unpaired counts do not imply equal orbital occupancy or geometry.