Aromatic Hydrocarbons — Question 9

Section 22-3 · Chemistry pages 3663–3664

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Use a vector model to compare substituted-ring dipoles

Model each of two identical ring substituents as an equal outward radial dipole of magnitude mu on a regular hexagon. Ignore all other contributions. The angle between dipoles is 60 degrees for ortho, 120 for meta and 180 for para. For two equal vectors, the resultant magnitude is 2μ2(1+cos⁡θ)\sqrt{2\mu^2(1+\cos\theta)}.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find each resultant in units of mu and rank them.

  2. Explain why cancellation in the para model does not mean its individual bonds are nonpolar or its molecules lack intermolecular attractions.

Question 9 - Solution

Use a vector model to compare substituted-ring dipoles

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Ortho gives 3μ\sqrt3\mu, meta gives μ\mu and para gives zero, so ortho > meta > para in this model. The two opposite equal vectors in para cancel.

(b) Analysis

Vector cancellation removes the net molecular dipole but not the local bond dipoles. Dispersion interactions remain, and real molecular polarization can differ from an additive bond-vector approximation. The model ranks the stated vector sums, not every physical property of the isomers.

Check and interpretation

Add vectors with directions, not just their magnitudes.