Aromatic Hydrocarbons — Question 10

Section 22-3 · Chemistry pages 3665–3666

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Avoid double-counting atoms in a fused aromatic framework

The naphthalene carbon skeleton consists of two six-membered rings sharing one edge and its two endpoint carbons. Its formula is C10H8. Define degree of unsaturation for a hydrocarbon as (2C+2−H)/2(2C+2-H)/2. A localized valence drawing has five C=C bonds.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Count distinct carbon atoms and C-C sigma connections, and calculate the degree of unsaturation.

  2. Reconcile that degree with the rings and localized pi bonds, and explain why assigning six independent pi electrons to each hexagon would overcount the fused system.

Question 10 - Solution

Avoid double-counting atoms in a fused aromatic framework

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Distinct carbons are 6+6−2=106+6-2=10. Distinct C-C sigma connections are 6+6−1=116+6-1=11. Degree of unsaturation is (22−8)/2=7(22-8)/2=7.

(b) Analysis

The graph has 11−10+1=211-10+1=2 independent rings and the localized drawing has five pi bonds, totaling seven. Ten sp2 carbons contribute ten pi electrons to the fused conjugated framework. The shared atoms are not two separate copies belonging independently to each hexagon; adding two six-electron inventories would count shared contributions twice.

Check and interpretation

Independent rings are counted from the connected graph, not by counting every possible closed path.