Show solutionHide solution
Question 6
Find a thermochemical cycle that does not close
For the same amount of a hypothetical material at fixed temperature and pressure, measurements report A to B: -40 kJ, B to C: -25 kJ, and C to A: +70 kJ. The labels specify complete states.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Test whether the three central values satisfy Hess's law.
If the first two are exact, what must the third be? What if each value has an independent bound of kJ?
Question 6 - Solution
Find a thermochemical cycle that does not close
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The cycle sum is kJ. A return to the identical state must give zero enthalpy change, so the central values are inconsistent.
(b) Analysis
The third must be +65 kJ. With independent bounds of 1 kJ each, the cycle sum can range only from +2 to +8 kJ, still excluding zero. Those bounds cannot explain the discrepancy.
Check and interpretation
An inconsistent cycle can reveal a phase mismatch, calibration bias or omitted step.