Exceptions to the Octet Rule — Question 9

Section 8-11 · Chemistry pages 1503–1504

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Reject an indiscriminate expanded-octet rule

A student proposes neutral NF5_5 with five ordinary N–F single bonds and three lone pairs on every F, arguing that its forty-electron budget works just as for PF5_5. N and P each contribute five valence electrons.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Verify the total budget and identify the separate shell-rule problem at N.

  2. Explain why electron-count agreement alone does not establish an ordinary stable molecule.

Question 9 - Solution

Reject an indiscriminate expanded-octet rule

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The drawing uses ten bonding plus thirty nonbonding electrons, matching 5+5(7)=405+5(7)=40. But it assigns ten electrons around second-period N, violating the ordinary second-period octet constraint.

(b) Analysis

A globally correct inventory is necessary but insufficient. Plausible shell occupancy, bonding energetics and structural evidence also matter. Expanded-octet drawings used for heavier central atoms cannot simply be transferred to second-period nitrogen.

Check and interpretation

This critique concerns the proposed ordinary five-two-center-bond molecule, not every exotic high-pressure or transient species.