Exceptions to the Octet Rule — Question 10

Section 8-11 · Chemistry pages 1505–1506

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Test electron parity rather than charge parity

Compare NH4+_4^+, NO and NO+^+. Use H = 1, N = 5 and O = 6 valence electrons. A student claims that every singly charged ion must be an odd-electron radical.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the valence electron count and parity of all three species.

  2. Explain what odd and even counts do, and do not, establish.

Question 10 - Solution

Test electron parity rather than charge parity

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

NH4+_4^+ has 5+4−1=85+4-1=8 electrons, even. NO has 5+6=115+6=11, odd. NO+^+ has 5+6−1=105+6-1=10, even.

(b) Analysis

An odd count requires at least one unpaired electron. An even count permits complete pairing but does not universally prove it, because some even-electron species have unpaired electrons. Charge sign or a charge magnitude of one alone does not determine parity.

Check and interpretation

Count the electrons of the actual species before applying an all-pairs model.