Question 1
Consider the initial-value problem
Tasks
Solve by separation, explaining how the initial condition selects the integration constant.
Find the maximal open interval containing on which the solution is finite and differentiable.
Determine its monotonicity, minimum, and behavior at both interval endpoints.
A student says that the periodicity of tangent extends this same solution through each vertical asymptote. Explain the error and verify the valid solution directly.
Show solutionHide solution
Question 1 – Solution
Strategy. Separate using the everywhere-positive factor , then respect the range of the inverse tangent.
Step 1: Integrate and select the branch. Thus near . No constant solution was lost, since never vanishes for real .
Step 2: Identify the interval and shape. For the branch through , we need . Hence The derivative has the sign of : the solution decreases to its minimum and then increases. At either endpoint approached from inside , the angle tends to from below, so .
Step 3: Verify and explain the obstruction. Differentiation gives , and . A real differentiable extension through an endpoint would have a finite, continuous value there, contradicting blow-up. Other tangent branches lie on separate intervals; periodicity does not connect them across a pole.
See the diagram in the original worksheet below.