Repeated Roots — Question 9

PDF ↗

Question 9

For L>0L>0 and strictly positive endpoint values a,ba,b, consider y″+2y′+y=0,y(0)=a,y(L)=b.y''+2y'+y=0,\qquad y(0)=a,\qquad y(L)=b. The same solution is defined beyond the observed interval.

Tasks

  1. Find the unique solution and justify uniqueness for every L>0L>0.

  2. Prove that it is strictly positive throughout [0,L][0,L] using the transformed quantity u=etyu=e^ty.

  3. Determine exactly which endpoint pairs make the response nonnegative for every future time t≥0t\ge 0, not just between observations.

  4. For L=1L=1, a=1a=1, b=e−2b=e^{-2}, find the first zero after the observed interval and determine the sign for all later times. Explain why positive endpoint observations did not guarantee permanent positivity.

Original worksheet page 1: question and worked solution for 3-4-009
Show solutionHide solution

Question 9 – Solution

Strategy. The exponential transformation turns the repeated-root endpoint problem into linear interpolation, but its continuation beyond the interval is extrapolation.

Step 1: Solve the endpoint equations. Write y=(A+Bt)e−ty=(A+Bt)e^{-t}. The first datum sets A=aA=a, and the second gives a+BL=beLa+BL=be^L. Thus y(t)=[a+beL−aLt]e−t.\boxed{y(t)=[a+\frac{be^L-a}{L}t]e^{-t}}. The two constants are uniquely determined because L≠0L\ne 0. This also proves existence by substitution into the repeated-root family.

Step 2: Prove positivity between the data points. For 0≤t≤L0\le t\le L, u(t)=ety(t)=(1−t/L)a+(t/L)beL.u(t)=e^ty(t)=(1-t/L)a+(t/L)be^L. The weights are nonnegative and sum to 1, while both endpoint values are positive. Hence u>0u>0 and therefore y>0y>0 throughout the closed interval.

Step 3: Determine when positivity persists. The affine function u=a+Btu=a+Bt starts positive. It remains nonnegative for all t≥0t\ge 0 exactly when B≥0B\ge 0. Equivalently, b≥ae−L.\boxed{b\ge ae^{-L}}. At equality, uu is constant and y=ae−ty=ae^{-t}. If b<ae−Lb<ae^{-L}, the slope of uu is negative and its eventual zero is unavoidable despite both observed values being positive.

Step 4: Check the concrete continuation. Here B=e−1−1<0B=e^{-1}-1<0, so y(t)=[1−(1−e−1)t]e−t.y(t)=[1-(1-e^{-1})t]e^{-t}. Its unique zero is tz=11−e−1=ee−1>1.\boxed{t_z=\frac 1{1-e^{-1}}=\frac e{e-1}>1}. The response is negative for every t>tzt>t_z and tends to zero from below. The given endpoint at 1 is indeed [e−1]e−1=e−2[e^{-1}]e^{-1}=e^{-2}. Linear interpolation of positive transformed data stays positive between them; extending that same negative-slope line beyond the interval eventually crosses zero. The endpoint data determine the continuation uniquely, but do not force it to preserve the observed sign forever.

Original worksheet page 2: question and worked solution for 3-4-009

Original worksheet layout. Use Enlarge or open the PDF for a closer view.