Fundamental Sets of Solutions — Question 4

PDF ↗

Question 4

The smooth functions u=t2u=t^2 and v=t3v=t^3 are proposed as a fundamental set for an equation y″+p(t)y′+q(t)y=0y''+p(t)y'+q(t)y=0 with continuous coefficients on ℝ\mathbb R.

Tasks

  1. Prove that u,vu,v are linearly independent as functions on ℝ\mathbb R.

  2. Prove that no such regular normalized equation on ℝ\mathbb R can have both as solutions. Explain why independence alone is insufficient.

  3. Find the normalized equation having both as solutions on (0,∞)(0,\infty) and verify that they form a fundamental set there.

  4. On (0,∞)(0,\infty), solve y(1)=0y(1)=0, y′(1)=1y\prime(1)=1 using the pair. Explain why its zero value and slope at zero do not contradict your conclusion about regular equations.

Original worksheet page 1: question and worked solution for 3-6-004
Show solutionHide solution

Question 4 – Solution

Strategy. Check both requirements: independence and membership in the solution space of one regular equation on the stated interval.

Step 1: Prove independence. If At2+Bt3=0At^2+Bt^3=0 for every real tt, then A+Bt=0A+Bt=0 for every nonzero tt. Evaluating at two distinct nonzero points forces A=B=0A=B=0.

Step 2: Reject the proposed regular equation. The nonzero function u=t2u=t^2 has u(0)=u′(0)=0u(0)=u'(0)=0. Uniqueness for continuous normalized coefficients would force it to equal the zero solution on ℝ\mathbb R. Equivalently, substitution at zero would require u″(0)=2=0u''(0)=2=0. Thus these independent functions cannot be a fundamental set for any equation of the stated kind.

Step 3: Work on a valid interval. Substituting the two functions for t>0t>0 gives 2+2tp+t2q=0,6t+3t2p+t3q=0.2+2tp+t^2q=0,\qquad 6t+3t^2p+t^3q=0. Subtracting tt times the first equation from the second yields p=−4/tp=-4/t, then q=6/t2q=6/t^2. Hence y″−4ty′+6t2y=0.\boxed{y''-\frac 4t y'+\frac 6{t^2}y=0.} Both residuals vanish, the coefficients are continuous on (0,∞)(0,\infty), and uv′−u′v=t4>0uv'-u'v=t^4>0 there, so the pair is fundamental.

Step 4: Fit and interpret. The data give A+B=0A+B=0, 2A+3B=12A+3B=1, so y=t3−t2\boxed{y=t^3-t^2}. Its polynomial extension has zero value and slope at zero, but the normalized equation is undefined there. A theorem requiring continuous coefficients on an interval containing zero cannot be applied to that extension.

See the diagram in the original worksheet below.

Original worksheet page 2: question and worked solution for 3-6-004

Original worksheet layout. Use Enlarge or open the PDF for a closer view.