Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Promotion changes energy, not electron number
A carbon atom is represented in an excited configuration instead of ground-state .
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Draw the excited valence-orbital occupancy with four unpaired electrons.
Compare total valence electrons and number of unpaired electrons before and after promotion.
Explain why promotion alone is not an explanation of methane’s four equivalent bonds.
Question 9 - Solution
Promotion changes energy, not electron number
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a)
Put one electron in 2s and one in each of the three 2p orbitals, as shown.
(b)
Both configurations contain four valence electrons. The ground-state arrangement has two unpaired electrons; this excited arrangement has four. Promotion costs energy because an electron occupies the higher-energy 2p subshell.
(c)
An s orbital and three p orbitals differ in shape and directionality. Merely changing their occupancy does not make four equivalent spatial bonding directions. Molecular bonding and, in a localized model, hybridization must also be considered; free-atom promotion is a bookkeeping component of that model.