Hydrohalogenation of Alkynes — Question 3

Section 10-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 2235–2236

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Repair a vicinal-product prediction for excess hydrogen bromide

The reagent is excess HBr under ionic conditions, not Br2.

Starting material
Student product
  1. Identify the error in the student product.

  2. Draw the usual principal product.

  3. Explain why reagent identity matters even though both products contain two Br atoms.

Question 3 - Solution

Repair a vicinal-product prediction for excess hydrogen bromide

Corrected product

(a)

The student placed the Br atoms on adjacent carbons, giving a vicinal dibromide.

(b)

The expected product is the geminal dibromide 2,2-dibromobutane.

(c)

Two additions of HBr deliver two H atoms and two Br atoms with repeated Markovnikov orientation; simply counting Br atoms does not determine connectivity.