Hydrohalogenation of Alkynes — Question 4

Section 10-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 2237–2238

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Check charge and bond order in a simplified protonation model

Use a simplified ionic electron-pair model: an alkyne pi pair bonds to H, and the H–Br pair returns to Br. The displayed ionization is bookkeeping, not a separate mechanistic assertion.

Propyne

HBr -> H+ + Br-\text{HBr -> H+ + Br-}

  1. Draw the Markovnikov vinyl-cation intermediate.

  2. How many pi bonds remain?

  3. Account for the total charge including bromide.

Question 4 - Solution

Check charge and bond order in a simplified protonation model

Vinyl cation in the stated model

Br-\text{Br-}

(a)

The model intermediate is CH2=C(+)-CH3, with positive charge at C2.

(b)

One pi bond remains; one original pi pair formed the new C–H bond.

(c)

The organic cation has charge +1 and bromide has -1, so the combined charge remains zero.