Friedel-Crafts Acylation — Question 2

Section 19-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 4333–4334

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Audit the two acylium resonance contributors

Both drawings represent the acetyl cation.

Contributor A
Contributor B
  1. Do their atoms have the same connectivity?

  2. Which contributor gives carbon an octet?

  3. Where is the net charge in each contributor?

Question 2 - Solution

Audit the two acylium resonance contributors

Contributor A
Contributor B

(a)

Yes. The CH3–C–O skeleton remains unchanged.

(b)

Contributor B, with a C–O triple bond, gives the acyl carbon an octet.

(c)

A places +1 on carbon; B places +1 on oxygen. Both represent one cation, not different intermediates.