Carbon Atoms with Formal Charges — Question 9

Section 2-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 347–348

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Count an aromatic carbon anion without inventing hydrogen

The explicitly labeled ring carbon has one single and one double ring bond, one lone pair, and no H. All other ring vertices follow normal skeletal conventions.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Phenyl anion; charged vertex has no H
  1. Verify the charge and octet at the labeled carbon.

  2. Count the hydrogens in the entire ion.

  3. Why would adding H at the labeled site violate the stated electron inventory?

Question 9 - Solution

Count an aromatic carbon anion without inventing hydrogen

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Phenyl anion; charged vertex has no H

(a)

The bond-order sum is three. With two nonbonding electrons, charge is 4−3−2=−14-3-2=-1; the surrounding count is eight.

(b)

The other five carbons each bear one H, so the formula is .

(c)

Keeping the lone pair and adding a fourth bond order would place ten electrons around this second-row carbon. The explicitly stated pair and charge constrain the implicit-H count.